Transgender Employment Study Results Announced

Photo by Lena Balk on Unsplash

New Report Examines Employment Disparities Among TGNCNB New Yorkers and Offers Policy Recommendations to Address Systemic Barriers

Builds on Governor Hochul’s Agenda to Support LGBTQIA+ New Yorkers and Expand Workplace Protections

Report Available Here

Governor Kathy Hochul announced the results of the Transgender Employment Study, a first-of-its-kind report that details the experiences of transgender, gender non-conforming and non-binary New Yorkers in the workplace. Governor Hochul signed legislation directing the New York State Department of Labor to conduct the study in consultation with the New York State Division of Human Rights. The full study is available here.

“As the birthplace of the LGBTQ+ civil rights movement, New York State has maintained a deep commitment to providing greater respect, stronger protections, and better opportunities for the LGBTQ+ community,” Governor Hochul said. “This report provides a glimpse into the work lives of trans, gender non-confirming, and non-binary New Yorkers and charts a path forward on addressing the barriers they face. New York remains committed to providing an open and affirming workplace for all workers, and my administration will continue to provide the resources and protections needed for every New Yorker to live free from discrimination.”

NYSDOL looked to determine whether employment disparities among TGNCNB individuals in New York State exist, evaluate factors contributing to those disparities, and recommend proposals to address barriers to equal employment. NYSDOL collected data through meetings with TGNCNB advocates and community leaders, five focus groups, interviews, and over 350 online public comments from counties in all ten regions of the state. This study will build on advancements to ensure New York State workplaces are safe and affirming for TGNCNB members of the workforce.

Key findings in the NYSDOL report include, but are not limited to:

• Employment discrimination based on gender identity is pervasive throughout the state.
• TGNCNB people of color experience greater employment disparities.
• There is a lack of cultural competency statewide regarding gender identity and expression.
• There is a genuine fear for safety in the workplace among TGNCNB individuals.
• Discrimination and other barriers to employment have led TGNCNB New Yorkers to seek self-employment opportunities.
• There is a regional difference between the experiences of TGNCNB individuals in New York City and other large cities, versus those in the more rural areas of the state.

By engaging with the TGNCNB community statewide, the report includes recommendations for policy that can be specifically tailored to the needs of TGNCNB New Yorkers. Surveys with TGNCNB respondents conducted in New York State, and nationwide, included in this report have found that transgender people face higher rates of unemployment, lower incomes, less educational attainment and higher rates of justice involvement due to discrimination. For example, a survey of TGNCNB individuals living in New York City by the Anti-Violence Project found that TGNCNB people of color with a bachelor’s degree experience significantly lower incomes than white TGNCNB individuals with the same degree.

The report recommends the following policy additions:

• Advocating for uniform data collection regarding gender identity by Federal agencies, especially the US Census Bureau.
• Providing workforce development programming specifically for TGNCNB communities to address their unique challenges.
• Mandating cultural competency and GENDA training across the State.
• Exploring additional ways the State can reduce barriers to obtaining affirming legal identification.
• Modeling best practices for employers.
• Addressing barriers to employment for justice-involved individuals.

Governor Hochul remains committed to supporting the LGBTQIA+ community, particularly the TGNCNB New Yorkers. In her first budget, Governor Hochul worked with the legislature to include a historic $13.5 million investment in LGBTQIA+ health and human services funding, including creating the Lorena Borjas Transgender Wellness and Equity Fund. Governor Hochul also expanded this fund from health and human services funding to include funding for TGNCNB youth suicide prevention. The Governor has also signed significant legislation to support TGNCNB New Yorkers by requiring state agencies to make an “X” gender designation available to the public on state forms that collect such information; designating New York state as a “safe haven” for TGNCNB youth, their parents, and health care providers; and enacting the Gender Inclusive Ballot Act. Governor Hochul also instructed the Office of General Services and the Office of Employee Relations to take actions to strengthen workplace inclusion for TGNCNB state employees, establishing a best practices model for other employers.

The entire State will benefit from greater workforce participation by TGNCNB New Yorkers. Correcting for years of under-employment and low wages will allow TGNCNB individuals to find new opportunities in local economies. By creating equitable and affirming workplaces, employers will see greater retention, saving money on recruitment and onboarding. As younger generations increasingly identify as gender diverse, New York is in a critical moment. The findings of this report will allow the State to work together with employers and workers to take the necessary steps to ensure all generations of workers have open and supportive employment experiences.

Any New Yorker who feels they have been discriminated against in the hiring process or workplace can file a complaint with DHR online, by mail, or in person. For more information about the law and the work of the agency, please visit the Division of Human Rights’ website at www.dhr.ny.gov or call 1-888-392-3644.